Why Most Writers Are Measuring the Wrong Thing (And What to Track Instead)

I've been obsessed with writing metrics for years.

Word counts, reading time, paragraph length, sentence structure—I track it all. But after analyzing thousands of pieces of content, I realized most writers are focusing on the wrong numbers.

They're measuring output instead of impact.

The Metric That Actually Matters

Last month, I read two articles on the same topic.

Article 1: 2,500 words, perfect grammar, impressive vocabulary
Article 2: 800 words, simple language, clear structure

Guess which one got shared more? Commented on more? Actually helped people?

The short one. By a landslide.

The difference wasn't length or complexity. It was clarity.

What I Learned From Building a Writing Tool

When I started building writing analysis tools, I thought people wanted to count words and check grammar. Those seemed like the "important" metrics.

But users kept asking for something else: "Can you tell me if this makes sense?"

They didn't want longer content. They wanted clearer content.

That's when I realized we've been measuring writing all wrong.

The Three Metrics That Actually Predict Success

After studying what makes content work, here are the only three numbers that really matter:

1. Comprehension Speed
How fast can someone understand your main point? If it takes more than 30 seconds to "get it," you've lost them.

2. Action Rate
How many people do something after reading? Share it, comment, bookmark, or apply your advice. This tells you if your content actually helped.

3. Return Rate
How many people come back for more? This is the ultimate test of value.

Everything else—word count, reading time, sentence length—are just tools to improve these three.

Why Most Writing Advice Misses the Point

We're taught to write longer for SEO. To use big words to sound smart. To follow complex formulas and templates.

But here's what actually happens:

• Longer doesn't mean better if people stop reading halfway through

• Big words don't impress if no one understands them

• Perfect structure means nothing if the content doesn't help anyone

The best writing feels effortless to read, even when the topic is complex.

The Simple Framework That Changed Everything

Now I measure writing differently:

Before publishing, I ask:

• Can a 12-year-old understand the main point?

• Would someone share this with a friend?

• Does this solve a real problem?

After publishing, I track:

• Comments that show understanding (not just "great post!")

• Shares with personal context added

• Direct messages from people who applied the advice

These numbers tell me if my writing actually worked.

What This Means for Your Writing

Stop chasing word counts and start chasing clarity.

Stop trying to sound impressive and start trying to be helpful.

Stop measuring how much you wrote and start measuring how much you helped.

The goal isn't to write more. It's to write better.

The One Question That Changes Everything

Before you publish anything, ask yourself:

"If someone spent 5 minutes reading this, would they be glad they did?"

If the answer is yes, hit publish. If not, keep editing.

That's the only metric that really matters.

---

Want to see how clear your writing really is? I built a tool that analyzes your content for readability, word count, and clarity metrics—the ones that actually matter for connecting with readers.

Check it out at WordCountAI.com and get instant feedback on whether your writing hits that "12-year-old can understand it" test we talked about.

No signup required. Just paste your text and see how it scores.